A vegetated surface serves several roles in the
control of stormwater.
The surfaces of the vegetation (leaves, twigs,
branches, rough bark) intercept and hold a portion of the rain,which then
evaporates back into the atmosphere before reaching the ground surface.
The more layers of vegetation (canopy, understory, shrub layer, ground
cover, leaf litter), the more interception that occurs. Precipitation that
is not intercepted, reaches the groundby drip through,either by dripping
or by running downthe trunk. Consequently the vegetative cover discipates
much of the energy of the rain drops and thus decreases the occurrence
of rainsplash erosion, which in turn initiates the process of surface
or sheet erosion during a storm. The vegetation reduces the occurrence
of sheet erosion by holding the soil particles in place with its roots
as the stormwater runs off along the surface.
Some of the precipitation enters the soil by
infiltration. Of this, some evaporates back into the atmosphere, some is
drawn down below the root zone by gravity where it may enter the water
table, and some is held in the root zone by the soil particles. The amount
held in the root zone is dependent upon the soil texture and structure.
Some of the water in the root zone enters the roots of the plants and is
released back into the atmosphere from the leaves of the plants by transpiration.
The deeper the roots go, the more water returned to the atmosphere, and
the less that remains in the soil.
Water in the soil occupies the spaces between
the soil particles, that would otherwise be occupied by air. As the volume
of water in the soil increases, it exerts a pressure on the soil particles
that pushes them apart. Water may also enter fractures in bedrock and the
water pressure may separate the rock faces from each other. On slopes this
may lead to slope failure or mass wasting, such as rock falls or slides.
Slides are brought about at planar surfaces, such as at the interface of
soil and the weathering surface of bedrock. As the soil particles are pushed
apart, they separate from the rock surface, thus the friction that held
them in place against gravity is reduced and a slide may occur.
The first effect is the increase in soil surface
erosion due to the loss of vegetation and its functions - interception,
holding the soil in place, and evapotranspiration.
The second is the increased chance of slope failures
due to the added downward weight of structures (buildings, roads, vehicles)
placed on the soil surface, and to increased entrance of water into the
soil. Thus a volume of ground water that was too small to cause a slump
under natural conditions, can now cause a slump as the added weight of
the structures overcomes the friction that held the soil in place. Or a
storm that would not have caused a problem now causes slope failure because
a greater percentage of the precipitation is entering the soil.
As a consequence of the above, human activities
on slopes should be controlled, and in some cases prevented. Although homes
can be built on slopes if their weight is transmitted directly to bedrock,
the fracturing of the bedrock must also be taken into account. "In urban
areas, the overloading of slopes is occurring more frequently as buildings
are sited on artificial fills on steep hillsides that were formerly avoided"
(Dunne and Leopold, 1978, p. 563). Human activities that alter the hydrology
of the hillslope, such as clearing of vegetation, diversion of stormwater
from roads or roofs, leakage of water from septic tanks, water pipes and
sewerage lines, or the use of dry wells, are frequent causes of damaging
landslides.
Sewage from the house enters the septic tank where
the organic compounds are partially broken down by bacteria. Effluent from
the tank contains many solid and soluble organic compounds, inorganic solutes
and bacteria. The effluent flows slowly through pipes in the filter field
and drains into the soil over a large area. "Bacterial action in the soil
further breaks down the solid and soluble organic compounds. Some of the
inorganic solutes become bound to soil particles, and the remaining solids,
including bacteria, are filtered out by the soil. The effluent then drains
to groundwater and streams with a greatly reduced potential for contamination"
(Dunne and Leopold, 1978, p. 184).
"For efficient operation the filter field should be located in a
large volume of soil into and through which the effluent can move easily.
The drain pipe should be buried below the topsoil, usually at a depth of
at least 60 cm. Below it there should be at least 1.5 m of soil above the
bedrock so that the effluent will be adequately filtered before reaching
the bedrock. ... Filter fields should terminate at least 15 m from a lake
or water course so that there is adequate distance for filtering of the
effluent within the soil" (Dunne and Leopold, 1978, p. 184).
"Filter fields ideally should not be located
on hillslopes with gradients greater than about 0.10 (10 percent), and
on such slopes should be laid along the contour and in a zig-zag pattern.
In this way, flow velocities within the drain pipes will be slowed and
the effluent will seep into the soil over the whole field. If the soil
is shallower than is ideal, the effluent may return to the ground surface
downslope of the drains on a steep hillslope" (Dunne and Leopold, 1978,
p.184).
"Some state health agencies allow the absorption
area per bedroom to be estimated from the texture of the soil" (Table 1),
butthis does not take into account the"hazard from seasonal waterlogging
or steep slopes" (Dunne and Leopold, 1978, p. 187).
Hillslopes can easily be destabilized by human
activities and by the occurrence of infrequent meteorological, as well
as seismic, events (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 1). The economic impact
of the mass movement of soil can be measured in terms of direct costs related
to damage to homes and other buildings; to personal property; to water
and gas pipes, storm and sanitary sewers, roads and sidewalks; and to street
and traffic lights, and other electric cables (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 5).
There are also indirect costs, such as implementing preventative
measures to reduce future impacts, loss of real estate values in the area
purchase of title to landslide prone properties by local government, loss
of tax
| Soil Texture | Absorption Area, ft3 bedroom |
| Gravel or coarse sand | 70 |
| Fine sand | 90 |
| Sandy loam | 115 |
| Clay loam | 150 |
| Sandy clay | 175 |
| Clay with a small amount of sand and gravel | 250 |
| Heavy clay | unsuitable |
revenues on conversion of private property to public property, damage
to personal property, lost time from work, legal fees, moving expenses,
and social costs; and emergency services (medical, housing and subsistence
(Sidle et al., 1985, p. 5). There are also impacts related to flooding
and sedimentation downstream.
There are five major types of soil mass movement: falls, topples, slides, lateral spreads, flows, and combinations thereof. These movements can occur in bedrock,in debris and in fine earth sediments (Sidle et al., 1985, p.11). Debris slides, avalanches, and flows, or combinations thereof, are the most common types of soil mass movement on managed and unmanaged steep (> 25o) slopes; these movements occur with high antecedent soil moisture levels and intense high volume rainfall (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 12). In addition to the above, soil erosion also occurs as "dry ravel," which consists of gravity initiated downslope movement of individual soil grains, aggregates and coarser fragments (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 18).
Several factors affect slope stability: pore water
pressure, soil strength parameters, slope gradient, and depth of soil to
potential fracture plane, as well as micro-fissure structure in clay regoliths,
pore-water chemistry, macropore networks in soil, and clay sensitivity
(Sidle et al., 1985, p. 26).
Geomorphic factors
a) Geologic and tectonic settings
Certain types of terrain are predisposed to mass movements because of geologic factors: structure, lithology and tectonic setting (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 31). Rock structures, such as bedding planes, folds, joints, and faults, affect the stability of natural hillslopes. Rocks of different competence may be separated by downslope dipping planes, which may, along with joints and fractures oriented in the same direction, impede vertical infiltration and root penetration, and may in turn act as failure planes. On the other hand, horizontal or cross-dip bedding may result in increased slope stability. "Fault zones often contain fractured, crushed, or partly metamorphosed rocks. The inherent geologic weakness of these zones can be increased by deep percolation of water into the bedrock and subsequent chemical weathering of crushed rocks into clay-rich soil, which is susceptible to slump-earthflow type failures" (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 32). Shallow soil layers lying on hard, massive or impermeable rocks on steep slopes or resistant flow rocks lying on clay-rich rocks are susceptible to mass movement of soil (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 34). Such soils may have little attachment to underlying crystalline igneous and metamorphic rocks and thus are subject to debris slides and avalanches.
b) Slope gradient
It is difficult to specify a lower limit of slope gradient for soil mass movements (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 36). Soil creep occurs on slopes that range in gradient from 1.3o to 25.0o. Rotational slumps occur on slopes of 7 to 18o. Rapid soil mass movement occurs on slopes greater than 25o, particularly when the soil layer is weakly attached to underlying rock. Soil lying on rock with slopes greater than 35o is subject to mass movement.
c) Slope shape
Slope shape has a major affect on the distribution of water content and thus on soil mass movement (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 38). Concave areas with ridges concentrate subsurface recharge water in small depressions and gullies on the slope, which raises pore pressures rapidly and makes the areas susceptible to debris-slides. Depressions and gullies may have soil layers twice as thick as on the upper slopes, which makes them even more susceptible to mass movements (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 38).
Hydrologic properties of soils
The rate of water movement within and water holding capacity of the soil are very important relative to slope stability (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 42-45). These soil properties are affected by the size distributions of particles and the spaces betweenthem, water input, slope gradient and shape, distance to water table, evapotranspiration and land use. Large spaces between soil particles, or macropores, are formed by decayed roots, earthworms, animal burrows, cracks from freeze-thaw or drying or subsurface erosion,and spaces between soil aggregates. Presence of macropores greatly increases the rate of water flow through the soil. Macropore size decreases with depth in the soil, which in turn influences the depth at which lateral subsurface flow occurs in the soil. Such lateral flow may occur in the upper permeable organic layers or at the interface with bedrock or other impermeable surface where shear stress is the greatest, and result in reduced shear strength and a shallow landslide. A high water holding capacity may result in retention of water from previous storms, antecedent moisture levels, and thus lessen the amount of precipitation in a following storm needed to saturate the soil. Thus thin soils on slopes recharge quickly and may lead to debris slides.
Engineering properties of soils
Shear strength of the soil is dependent on the
normal stress on the slip surface, cohesion of soil particles, and the
internal angle of friction (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 45-46). The normal stress
is affected by the weight or density of the soil, which increases with
increased moisture content, the soil depth and slope gradient. Water infiltrating
into the soil increases the weight of the soil and the water pressure within
the soil pores and brings about unstable conditions. Soil cohesion is brought
about by electromagnetic attraction between soil particles, cementing by
organic and inorganic materials, and surface tension in unsaturated clay
particles. Cohesion is limited by the point at which water content deforms
the soil enough to cause rupture, the amount of water needed to cause the
soil to flow. The internal angle of friction or degree of interlocking
of soil particles and aggregates is dependent on the shape, size, and packing
arrangement of the soil particles. Physical and chemical weathering
of primary minerals, such as biotite and pyroxenes, results in production
of clay particles (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 46).
Stability of hillslopes is dependent on hydrologic
processes such as rainfall, rate of infiltration into the soil, subsurface
flow rate, and evapotranspiration (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 48-51). Overland
flow tends to be minimal in vegetated, undisturbed areas, and thus the
major downslope flow is subsurface. If the infiltration rate is greater
than the downslope transmission rate, the excess is pulled by gravity into
the deeper layers of the soil to form or add to the groundwater; shear
strength in this deeper layer of the soil drops. Tension cracks, soil pipes
and macropores in the soil may also divert subsurface flow downward into
the deeper soil layers. Increasing water flow into deeper layers brings
water into potenial failure zones and decreases slope stability.
Transpiration by vegetation reduces soil water content (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 54). Trees transpire more than do understory shrubs or short ground vegetation due to their higher surface roughness (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 54-55). Vegetation types with deeper roots are able to transpire more water and dry the soil to greater depths. Evapotranspiration may thus reduce slow soil movement, or earthflow, rates.
Groundwater-slope stability relationships
Increases in pore water pressure increase the likelihood of shallow rapid slope failures (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 57). Vegetation removal decreases transpired soil water loss and thus increases soil moisture levels; this can result in increased rates of soil slumps and creeps.
Clearcutting of forests is followed over a 10 year period by increasing number and size of shallow landslides (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 58-59, 63, 65, 66). The length of the period is related to the time involved in decay of tree roots, with 50% or more of the tensile strength lost on the average in 2 years. The actual occurrence of landslides is dependent upon root deterioration, occurrence of a storm at or above the failure threshold and specific site factors, such as slopes over 30%. Roots are particularly important in increasing soil cohesion and shear strength when they cross shear zones. While alive the roots are able to stretch and readjust their positions when under peak shear stress.
Influence of roots on slope stability
Roots increase slope stability in several ways (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 60-62).
1. Roots can penetrate through failure prone surface layers into more stable deeper layers within the root zone and thus increase slope stability.
2. Roots can form a dense interwoven network in the upper 50cm of forest soil, which holds the soil in place.
3. Roots of a tree can form a localized center for soil reinforcement. With appropriate spacing of trees, the roots can provide soil arching restraint and increase shear strength of the soil.
Root deterioration and its effect on slope stability
With the forest intact, the roots stabilize the soil in two ways: they anchor the soil in place by passing through loose material at the surface to more compact layers beneath, and they provide channels along the roots for rapid subsurface drainage which reduces the risk of surface soil saturation during heavy storms (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 66).
Failure of rock masses, as well as of soil material, is frequently
triggered by seismic events (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 66, 68).
The effect of forest cover removal is dependent on the density of
remaining trees and shrubs, the rate and type of regenerating vegetation,
site characteristics, and water input (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 73-74, 76).
Partial removal of trees exposes the remaining forest stand to wind action
and blowdowns, which can further increase landsliding. Conversion of hillside
vegetation from trees to grasses increases the rates of mass movement.
In the early 1970s the US Federal Highway Administration
estimated it spent $50 million a year to repair landslide damage (Sidle
et al., 1985, p. 79). However, low traffic volume roads are built without
the extensive engineering and preventative control measures which are used
in federally funded highway systems. Low volume roads are frequently constructed
on steep slopes and decrease slope stability in four ways: 1) embankment
fill adds weight to slope, 2) slope is increased on both cut and fill surfaces,
3) support is removed on the cutslope, and 4) concentration and rerouting
of stormwater from road surface. Blockage of, lack of, or too few culverts,
can cause soil saturation from storm water runoff in specific areas on
the fill slope, which brings about slope failure. Routing of runoff into
slope depressions can bring about shallow, rapid failures.
Recent urban development on hillsides has increased landslide activity, particularly on fill and cut slopes (Sidle et al., 1985, p. 84-86). Slope stability is decreased in several ways: "(1) removal of support by excavation, (2) mechanical overloading by fill placement, (3) concentration of water on the site or introduction of additional water, and (4) extensive removal or conversion of vegetation" or a combination of the above. Introduction of additional water involves water from septic tanks, swimming pools, artificial ponds, dry wells and other concentrated storm runoff, leakage from sewer lines, and from irrigation or watering of vegetation. Where slopes are more stable, soil creep may be accelerated, which in turn may cause damage to residences and public services. Cutslopes can cause debris avalanches on highly weathered, jointed bedrock, due to loss of lateral slope support. "Fill material and structures placed on hillslopes load the existing terrain and must be carefully engineered. Compaction of fill material is critically important to increase fill strength and minimize subsurface water inputs from upslope. Organic material and live vegetation should be excluded from fills to prevent eventual settlement and slope failure. Natural instability factors, such as compressible soils and extensive subsurface seepage, should be avoided in fill sites." Revegetation can reduce shallow slides and surface erosion; however, grasses and herbs are limited to reducing only surface erosion. On slopes over 45o strong rooted woody shrubs are preferable to trees, as trees add weight to the slope and transmit vibrations to the soil when subject to heavy winds.
Detailed information and references are given in Sidle et al., (1985, Chapter 6) in relation to engineering and control methods to reduce slope destabiliztion. Specifically cited are the Uniform Building Code of the International Conference of Building Officials, the grading code for Los Angeles, and papers by Erley and Kockelman (1981), Leighton (1976), Neilsen et al. (1979), and Slosson (1969). The Los Angeles code restricts construction on slopes over 26o, has mandatory setbacks from cut and fill slopes, and sets specific requirements in relation to drainage around buildings, grading during the rainy season, thickness of fill, moving of soil, and as to size and type of grading equipment; it also sets up a schedule of seven mandatory inspections during construction. In some locations regulations have been set on lot sizes, such as one residence per 1.6 ha on a 24% slope, or on the percentage of the site that must remain in a natural state.
Serpentine is a hydrous magnesium silicate with a hardness ranging
from 2 to 5 (Leet and Judson, p. 480-481). Talc or soapstone is also a
hydrous magnesium silicate with a hardness of 1, which makes it the softest
of all rocks. Serpentine rock can be converted into a talc-magnesite on
exposure to carbon dioxide in the process of weathering (see below).
Once formed, rocks may undergo metamorphic changes as they are subjected
to different conditions of temperature (up to a maximum of 800oC at which
point the rock melts), pressure and chemical environment, and thus may
vary depending on the pH and mineral content of the surrounding material
(Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 511). These changes in environmental conditions
bring about extensive changes in the structure and chemical composition
of the rock (while the rock remains solid), so that it is now considered
to be metamorphic rock. Mafic minerals are rich in Mg and Fe. The
igneous rocks which fall into this group are pyroxene, amphibole, and olivine
(Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 101). The so called ultramafic rocks
are composed of more than 90% mafic material; for instance, dunite is 90
to 100% olivine and the remainder is mostly pyroxine (Ehlers and Blatt,
1982, p. 106). The main chemical constituents of ultramafic rocks
are MgO and SiO2, with small amounts of FeO and CaO. Metamorphism
of these minerals usually involves reactions with water and to a lesser
extend with carbon dioxide (Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 637-638). Thus prior
to metamorphic changes, ultramafic rocks can be thought to range in composition
from mostly MgO to mostly SiO2. During metamorphism the water
and/or carbon dioxide content of the rock increases as a result of the
processes of hydration and carbonation. Formation of serpentine, or serpentinization,
is one of the most common of these metamorphic reactions when igneous ultrabasic
rock (with a chemical composition intermediate between Mg2SiO4
and MgSiO3, such as found in olivine and pyroxine) is hydrated
on exposure to water at temperatures around 400° C. The chemical composition
of serpentine can be generalized as Mg3Si2O5(OH)4.
Hydration of an ultramafic igneous rock with a slightly higher content
of SiO2 leads to the formation of talc, Mg3Si4O10(OH)2.
In fact serpentinite, which is derived by hydration of primarily olivine
and pyroxene, contains accessory minerals such as talc, chlorite and carbonates
(Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 516).
Serpentinization involves induction of water
into a rock and subsequent hydration under high temperatures, which in
turn results in either an increase in volume, or a decrease in density
of the solid rock and increased porosity. This involves loss of Mg and
Si and/or increased internal fracturing (Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 639).
Igneous and metamorphic rocks are mechanically
unstable when exposed to the atmosphere (Ehlers and Blatt, 1982, p. 268-282).
They were formed under high temperatures (above 200o C) and pressures with
exposures to relatively low levels of oxygen and water as compared to levels
in the atmosphere. It is this instability that leads to breakdown of the
rock to form sediments or soil. The stability of minerals varies with iron-oxides
being the most stable, amphibole and pyroxene low in stability,
and olivine the least stable (Press and Siever, 1978, p. 97); pyroxine
and olivine are the minerals that give rise to serpentine on metamorphosis,
as indicated above). Thus the mafic minerals from which serpentine is formed
are highly susceptible to weathering when exposed at the surface due to
the low ironoxide content. Once formed, serpentinite is susceptible
to alteration on exposure to carbon dioxide, a normal component of rainwater
which has been absorbed during passage through the atmosphere. If the water
in contact with the rock contains more than 5% carbon dioxide (carbon dixide
dissolved in water forms carbonic acid), chrysolite and lizardite are eliminated
from that portion of the rock to leave a talc-magnesite zone. Thus the
fractured nature of serpentine leads to penetration of water throughout
the rock and creation of talc-magnesite zones within the serpentine formation.
"Various degrees of alteration may be found, from a thin rim of talc-magnesite
around the serpentinite body to almost complete replacement" (Ehlers and
Blatt, 1982, p. 640).
Serpentine rock is composed of three minerals
which differ in their fracturing or way in which they break up. The fracturing
type can only be detected by x-ray diffraction techniques (Ehlers and Blatt,
1982, p. 639). Lizardite tends to be platy, chrysotile fibrous, and antigorite
either fibrous or platy. Fibrous minerals differ greatly in chemical composition,
but can be used to make heat and fire resistant fabrics, insulating boards
and shingles. Because of its fibrous structure, chrysotile serpentine has
been used to produce 95% of the asbestos produced in the United States
(Leet and Judson, 1958, p.438).
Thus in the process of metamorphism and chemical
weathering, ultramafic rocks are reduced in hardness from 5-7 to a hardness
of 2-5 for serpentine and then to a hardness of 1 for talc. Hardness is
related to the strength of bonding between atoms and ions that make up
the rock (Press and Siever, 1978, p. 69-70). Covalent bonding is stronger
than ionic bonding and van der Waals bonding is the weakest. The weakness
of talc is because its silicate layers are weakly held to each other by
van der Waals bonding, and thus the layers slip and break apart easily.
Dunne, T. and L. B. Leopold. 1978. Water in Environmental Planning.
W. H. Freeman and
Co., San Francisco, 818 p.
Ehlers, E. G. and H. Blatt. 1982. Petrology: Igneous, Sedimentary,
and Metamorphic.
W. H. Freeman and Co., San Francisco, 732 p.
Erley, D. and W. J. Kockelman. 1981. Reducing landslide hazards:
A guide for planners.
Plan. Advisory Serv. Rep. 359. Am. Plan. Assoc.,
Chicago, Ill., 29 p.
Leet, L. D. and S. Judson. 1958. Physical Geology, 2nd edition. Prentice-Hall,
Inc.,
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey, 502 p.
Leighton, F. B. 1976. Urban landslides: Targets for land-use planning
in California. Geol.
Soc. Am. Spec. Pap. 174, pp. 37- 60.
Nielsen,T. H., R. H. Wright, T. C. Vlasic, and W. E. Spangle. 1979.
Relative slope stability
and land-use planning in the San Francisco Bay
Region, California. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof.
Pap. 944, 96 p.
Press, F. and R. Siever. 1978. Earth, 2nd edition. W. H. Freeman
and Co., San Francisco,
649 p.
Sidle, R. C., A. J. Pearce and C. L. O'Loughlin. 1985. Hillslope stability and land use.
Water Resources Monograph Series, Volume 11. American Geophysical
Union,
Washington, D.C.
Slosson, J. E. 1969. The role of engineering geology in urban planning.
Colo. Geol.
Surv. Spec. Publ. 1, pp. 8-15.
U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare. 1958. Manual of
septic tank practice.
Public Health Service Publication No. 526 (with
addenda in 1959, 1961). U.S.
Goverment Printing Office, Washington, D.
C.